Pet Lover Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Opinions on...

who's talking here?

Gator 5
4ever love3 3
Doberdiva 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Same sex dogs in one household.

I currently have two females and a male and they all get along beautifully (minus the annoying puppy factor towards the seniors) but the girls are a year apart and have never squabbled.

I will eventually move out and take the male dog with me and will get another dog ASAP.... I don't mind adopting a female but all the dogs I've been interested in are males...

My boy is neutered and any dog in my house is snipped so that's not an issue.

My boyfriend also has a neutered male and the dogs are involved with pretty much everything so I'm thinking three males will just cause issues..

What do y'all think? Experience with same sex dog aggression? 

Doberdiva --- 15 years ago -

I know plenty of people with multiple males and no issues, and I know others who have it completely MISERABLE. It can be done, you might have no problems, but just be prepared that if they have problems with each other, it can get ugly real fast and get ready for a lifetime of crate and rotate and never leaving them out together.

I prefer male dogs myself and my boyfriend wants to get a male Beauceron next. We already have 2 males and they are generally fine around each other but if the little one tries to mess with the big one it is on like Donkey Kong so I have to watch them like a hawk. If you're not experienced in handling it, I would say go with a female, unless you are prepared and dedicated to deal. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Yeah I don't want to risk it... Plus my male doxie is just one of those dogs that wants to be in charge of other dogs (constantly correcting him when he gets too pushy!) and if he is playing with another dog and the dog accidentally hurts him he doesn't yelp and leave like normal dogs.... He gets ticked off and escalates to actual fighting. One time my mom accidentally caught his tail in the door and my lab was standing behind him and I guess he thought it was her and he freaked. He always stops when corrected and nobody is ever injured but that's because my girls wouldn't know how to fight if their life depended on it lol


I worried that he will do it to the wrong dog and that dog will like eat him...

All this behavior started AFTER some dude brought his dog into my BF's apt, offleash without telling anyone, and gator ran out there and started to try to play and that dog attacked him. noone was hurt and it ended quickly but ever since then he's been very wary of new dogs and gets nervous when other dogs approach him :(

I want him to be well socialized and he was on the right track until that happened (he was like 5 months) and now I'm too nervous to bring him to the dog park for more socialization because of the way he acts :(

That was off topic lol but yeah I'll probably get a female next just to be safe :) 

4ever love3 --- 15 years ago -

I have 3 male dogs and 4 females the males only get rough when one of the females are in heat so I don't think you'll have much of a problem since they are all fixed. My doment dog is a poodle andy pit doesn't do anything to him even when the girls are in heat. The only problem I have with the boys is that they will mark evrything for a while until you put a stop to that as well. But all in all they behave themselves rather nicely 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Yeah no balls in my house lol or females in heat so that isn't the issue


I was just reading stuff last night and most people said don't do it... I'm just the type of person that wants all the dogs in the house to get along and I don't tolerate fights, not even small ones. There is no reason for it and they are NOT the boss... I am... my current dogs never fight (minus the puppy freaking out on the other two a few times, but he got corrected so fast his little head spun lol and he hasn't done it in a LONG time).


I think two males I would be comfortable with but my BF's dog is male also and big and whenever we hang out the dogs come too so three males just doesn't sit right with me...

I would die if anything happened to my dog so I don't want him being miserable if I get another male and they start fighting 

4ever love3 --- 15 years ago -

I supose. Idk my dogs never got into it you know they just stare at each other then move on lol 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

I supose. Idk my dogs never got into it you know they just stare at each other then move on lol


haha stare down.

yeah I mean I was reading a bunch of different articles and most of them said that males are MORE likely to start fights with each other but female on female fights are more vicious and end up with injuries more often...

My females never even stare each other down so I know it's a case by case basis...

I just don't want to get a male and then they start fighting because once I adopt a dog it would pretty much have to eat a couple people before I would consider doing something with it.

Hopefully I just fall in love with a female and save myself some trouble lol 

4ever love3 --- 15 years ago -

Lol yup good luck 

Doberdiva --- 15 years ago -

I was just reading stuff last night and most people said don't do it... I'm just the type of person that wants all the dogs in the house to get along and I don't tolerate fights, not even small ones. There is no reason for it and they are NOT the boss... I am... my current dogs never fight (minus the puppy freaking out on the other two a few times, but he got corrected so fast his little head spun lol and he hasn't done it in a LONG time).


It doesn't matter how much in control you are of your dogs, if two male dogs want to fight you are not going to stop them. You're just going to have to manage it. It is not something that can be trained out of them. At one point I had zelda, a male GSD, and a male husky that I was fostering. I wanted to keep the husky and he and the male GSD got along great in the beginning BUT months down the road a switch flipped and both of them were at each other's throats non-stop. I tried every training method and behavior modification method in the book but they just flat out hated each other. It got to the point where if they even caught a glimpse of each other from across a room the husky was ready to tear into the GSD. He put a few puncture holes in his neck before I finally decided it wasn't worth it and I adopted out the husky instead of fostering him any longer. These males were both neutered by the way!

I have put the fear of Jesus into my Doberman for going after my male pom, but even then, he still does not like the little guy. Novice or Professional, like I said..you're not going to stop two male dogs that want to go after each other unless you manage them. 

Doberdiva --- 15 years ago -

All this behavior started AFTER some dude brought his dog into my BF's apt, offleash without telling anyone, and gator ran out there and started to try to play and that dog attacked him. noone was hurt and it ended quickly but ever since then he's been very wary of new dogs and gets nervous when other dogs approach him :(

I want him to be well socialized and he was on the right track until that happened (he was like 5 months) and now I'm too nervous to bring him to the dog park for more socialization because of the way he acts :(



Ugh that sucks and I feel for you. I would be SO pissed. Unfortunately some dogs can recover emotionally and end up ok, but for others they never fully shake the traumatic experience and it will effect them around other dogs for the rest of their life. I am home now so I will respond to your message on FB :) 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

I'll just get a girl haha not worth the risk and I like females too... Plus I always see super cute Gorky collars an leashes and I can never buy them! Lol


Thanks everyone! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pet Lover Underground